Rap feuds tend to leave scars nobody expects, and right now the internet cannot agree on what those scars sound like on record.
Drake is at the center of that argument again. His ninth studio album, Iceman, arrived on May 15 alongside two surprise companion projects, Habibti and Maid of Honour, forming an unusual same-day trilogy. The Toronto rapper surprise-dropped a pair of additional albums, making for a trio of records amounting to 43 tracks across 149 minutes. The rollout leaned theatrical, built around a giant ice sculpture stunt in downtown Toronto that reportedly required police intervention.
The music itself has split listeners down the middle. Fantano, the YouTube critic behind The Needle Drop, gave Iceman one of the harshest scores of Drake's career. "This album is Drake at his saddest, his lowest point ever," he said, adding that he hoped it could only go up from here, calling it "pretty much rock bottom." He awarded the album a "light two" out of ten. Fantano also argued that it has become increasingly clear that the rapper doesn't quite have the "juice" that he used to.
Pitchfork was similarly unimpressed. The publication, which has praised previous Drake albums, gave the record a 4.8 out of 10 in a review by Jayson Greene. Writing for Consequence, Kiana Fitzgerald offered a more clinical read on the fatigue critics keep describing, noting that "Drake hasn't absorbed the trauma of what he's been through" and that she "can understand why, the poor thing, but it's becoming a bit of a problem".
Not every outlet piled on. Clash's Joe Simpson found real feeling underneath the grievance, writing that Iceman "makes it evident from kick off that the scars of [Drake's feuds] are still painful for [him]", and even calling Iceman Drake's best album since Her Loss, though he flagged its bloated runtime.
That divide echoes an older complaint. Reviewing Drake's 2025 collaboration with PARTYNEXTDOOR, Fantano wrote that the tracks blend together into a "sleepy, soft, porno soundtrack vibe that doesn't really leave much of an impression". The same word keeps resurfacing now, applied to an artist many feel is coasting on lawsuits and old grudges instead of urgency.
Fans see something else entirely. Given the ongoing Kendrick Lamar feud and Drake's active litigation against Universal Music Group, supporters argue the quieter delivery reads as genuine burnout, not creative decline.
Industry voices have mostly sided with the record. Jack Harlow described Iceman as his favorite release from Drake's 2026 album trilogy, while producers and peers praised individual cuts online.
Fantano has confirmed he will review Maid of Honour and Habibti next, meaning this critical tug of war is far from finished.
Check topics and authors from this story to see more stories like this in your personalized feed and receive updates when new work is published.
