When a franchise revival promises nostalgia, audiences expect comfort, not grief.
The four-part series finale of Wizards Beyond Waverly Place aired August 4 on Disney Channel, and it delivered a gut punch nobody anticipated: Mason Greyback, played by Gregg Sulkin, died at some point between the original show and its sequel. Alex Russo, reprised by Selena Gomez, discovered the truth while navigating alternate dimensions during the finale.
At the end of Season 2, it was suspected that Gomez's Alex had died, and fans spent months speculating she had simply slipped into another dimension. The finale event revealed instead that a different character was actually gone: Sulkin's Mason, whose return had been confirmed earlier this year, appeared only to deliver the devastating news.
In the scene, Alex eagerly urges Mason to propose. He refuses. "I can't propose to you. And you know why," he tells her. "Because you're dead," Alex answers after regaining her memories. Fearing she had also died, Alex learns from Mason that she ended up somewhere in between worlds, and that he returned from beyond to help her get back.
The reasoning behind the decision, according to co-star and executive producer David Henrie, was essentially narrative arithmetic. "We always wanted to bring Mason back, but it's a double-edged sword any route you choose," Henrie told TVLine. "Let's say they broke up, fans would be furious because they were the 'best relationship ever.' You know, how could you break them up and then have her go with a different guy? That doesn't make any sense. And then why do we even bring him back? So it was a double-edged sword, and the cleanest version was to kill him."
Sulkin fully supported the choice. "Yeah, it would be tough if you kept me in the picture," the actor told Henrie. In a separate interview with Deadline, he struck a more sentimental note: "I mean, I think, in my heart, Alex and Mason are always endgame."
Fans, predictably, are not handling it well. Viewers expressed disappointment over the lack of any explanation for Mason's off-screen death, and frustration that original cast members Jake T. Austin and David DeLuise were absent from the final season. One Reddit commenter called it "horrible writing," adding: "No explanations about Mason's death, like he's just dead." On X, one fan lamented, "Ok we need them to stop rebooting shows."
Henrie acknowledged that backlash was already building before the finale aired. Fans were furious, he said, when Season 2 confirmed Alex had a daughter, "because, obviously, that kid can't come from Gregg." The revelation meant Mason could not be Billie's biological father. Alex ended up reunited with her husband Damien Penwulf, played by Brandon Micheal Hall, along with their daughter Billie, played by Janice LeAnn Brown. Keeping Mason alive would have forced an impossible love-triangle choice.
The original Wizards of Waverly Place aired for four seasons, plus a TV movie, on Disney Channel from 2007 to 2012. That show launched Gomez into a superstar. Its revival had been a considerable hit too, racking up more than 101 million views on Disney Channel's YouTube account. Gomez herself made her directorial debut helming the premiere episode of the four-part finale.
For a franchise built on magical problem-solving, killing a fan-favorite werewolf is a strikingly permanent solution. Whether it reads as brave storytelling or careless disposal of legacy depends entirely on how much the audience trusted the writers to get this right.
Based on the first 24 hours, the verdict is mixed at best.
Check topics and authors from this story to see more stories like this in your personalized feed and receive updates when new work is published.
