Skip to content

Etsy Artist Exodus Forces Company to Promise Revised AI Terms

An editorial graphic bathed in a warm burnt-orange tint shows an ornate museum gallery room with patterned wallpaper, white wainscoting, and classic gilt-framed oil paintings, including a prominent upper portrait of a powdered gentleman, a large floral still life on the left, and a classical landscape at the bottom center, while small bronze sculptures rest on display pedestals on either side; centered over the wall is a translucent white prohibition symbol (a circle with a diagonal slash) behind the bold white serif wordmark "Etsy," symbolizing a boycott of the online marketplace.

Sellers and shoppers call for an Etsy boycott amid ongoing disputes over platform policies, fees, and AI training rights. Photo: Jackson's Art; Logo: Etsy/Design: PakistaniArt

Longtime sellers are deleting shops built over a decade, and Etsy says it's listening

Holiday season is usually when Etsy's handmade economy hums loudest. This year it's humming with goodbye notes instead.

A wave of sellers has been shutting down their shops over the past week, posting illustrated farewell flyers on Instagram and warning customers to find them elsewhere. The trigger is a quiet line buried in Etsy's updated Terms of Use, published October 26 and set to take effect December 16. Under the new language, Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" will have the right to use sellers content to "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies."

Illustrator Aaron Millard was among the first to go public. He ran his shop for nearly a decade before deleting it. "Etsy decided that selling on their platform now means letting them train AI on our artwork AND resell that data to third parties, with no way to opt out," Millard wrote on Instagram.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Aaron Millard on Instagram: "This one sucks to write.
8 years, 11,200 sales, 3k+ reviews, hundreds in a customer base. Deleted.

Etsy decided that selling on their platform now means letting them train AI on our artwork AND resell that data to third parties, with no way to opt out (in Canada, anyways). [Source: https://www.etsy.com/legal/terms-of-use ]

So I'm walking away. Right before the holiday rush. It's terrifying, and it is going to hurt me so, so much financially. But, my work took years to learn and create. I won't let it be stolen. It's not free fuel for an AI slop business model.

If you want to support an independent human artist making silly things, you can find my cards, stickers, and gifts on my site (And as of now, only on my site)

www.aaronmillard.com
.
#SupportArtists #HumanArt #NoAI #SupportSmallBusiness #MadeInToronto"

Stationery and home goods brand Cognitive Surplus followed. The shop had been on Etsy for 13 years. Both Millard and the owners of Cognitive Surplus accused Etsy of letting outside companies use their art.

Cognitive Surplus on Instagram: "TLDR: we closed our Etsy shop due to their new policies. You can support us directly on our website: cognitive-surplus.com

Well, this one hurts. After 13 years on Etsy as a star seller, 67k sales and almost 12k reviews (4.9⭐), we deleted everything.

A quiet little update to Etsy’s Terms & Conditions states that by selling on their platform, we automatically give Etsy perpetual, free, boundless permission to not only train AI on our art, but also to resell the data for profit. No ability to opt out. 

So we killed it. We’re out. Every listing, all our content, and our ability to stay in contact with all the customers we’ve served since our company first started. 

The timing is terrible – it’s right before the busiest weeks of the year. We’re scared for the financial impact the loss of this sales channel will have on our small business and the amazing people we have the honor of working alongside, and we’re sad to have to walk away after all the time and energy spent building and tending our little shop. 

But we do not use AI in our artwork, and we refuse to let Etsy feed all our hard work into the AI slop-machine.

If you want to support real people running a small business in the USA this holiday season, you can find all of our nerdy science-inspired stationery and gifts on our website:
cognitive-surplus.com

If you can’t support us this year, we get it. It’s been a hard year. Leaving a comment or dropping us a like will help get the word out about what Etsy is doing. 

Whatever you do this year, try to support real people rather than mega companies and billionaires. Your support makes a difference to small businesses like ours. It makes good jobs for good humans and it keeps money in the local economy. You’ll probably see other Etsy makers and sellers leaving the platform too - try and follow them, sign up for their mailing lists and maybe even pick up some holiday gifts. 

If you want to read Etsy’s new Terms and Conditions they are here:
https://www.etsy.com/legal/terms-and-conditions

#NoAI #HumansNotRobots #SupportSmallBusiness #Etsy"

Their posts spread fast. Etsy reviews, Reddit threads and Substack newsletters picked up the story within days, with sellers swapping notes on where to relocate inventory before the holiday rush.

The backlash caught Etsy off guard. James Ossman, the company's vice president of customer operations, posted a clarification on the Etsy Community site addressing the uproar directly. "We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity," he wrote. "Again, this is not changing." He added that sellers keep ownership of their work and that Etsy doesn't hand that ownership to anyone else.

Ossman also laid out specific uses already underway. He listed Etsy's uses of AI: automatically translating listing descriptions, featuring listings in marketing campaigns, and training models on sellers' content to create tools for monitoring shop performance, optimizing listings and providing statistics summaries. He said unauthorized scraping is barred outright. Ossman said Etsy prohibits AI crawlers from scraping listings to train models. He acknowledged that the company allows some third-party partners to access sellers' content, including services that help detect fraud and partners that can help buyers discover sellers' items off Etsy.

Advertisement

Advertisement

None of that reassurance lives inside the actual contract. Critics were quick to point out the gap. Ossman's commitment doesn't exist within the actual terms of service, which states only that Etsy and partners can "use Your Content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies." A spoken pledge from an executive doesn't carry the weight of the document sellers are bound by. One analysis put it bluntly: a statement of intent from an executive doesn't bind a contract, and sellers should read the revised version line by line and compare it to the October 26 text.

The opt-out question has proven just as murky. There's still no dedicated settings switch. Cybernews and seller-focused outlet Value Added Resource both reported there was no switch in account settings to keep work out of AI training. The terms point to opt-out rights in the Privacy Policy, and in practice a seller who wanted out had to email Etsy's data protection officer. For sellers already stretched thin during the holiday rush, that's not exactly a frictionless exit.

Advertisement

Advertisement

The license itself raises its own red flags. The license sellers grant Etsy was already non-exclusive, worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, sublicensable and perpetual. Deleting a shop may stop future uploads. It doesn't obviously claw back what's already been licensed.

Facing sustained pressure, Etsy told the New York Times on Friday it would act. Etsy told The New York Times it will revise its new terms of use after longtime sellers started closing their shops over a clause that lets Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" use seller content to train AI. The terms, which take effect December 16, give US sellers no clear way to keep their work out of AI training while still selling on Etsy. Ossman confirmed a new version is coming. Etsy VP of customer operations James Ossman said Etsy won't train AI designed to copy sellers' work and that the company is clarifying the terms and will send the revised version to sellers soon.

Advertisement

Advertisement

What the revision actually changes is anyone's guess until it lands. Reporting on the walk-back has been careful to note its limits. That is a retreat, but a narrower one than some headlines suggest. Etsy has not said it will never train AI on seller content. It has said it won't train the kind of AI that imitates sellers.

Timing hasn't helped Etsy's case. Just weeks before the terms controversy, the company earned goodwill for cracking down on AI slop. Starting in July, Etsy introduced four new labels that categorize product listings based on the seller's role in creating the item. Sellers now see that crackdown and the AI training clause as contradictory signals from the same company. One roundup of the saga noted the contrast directly: within four days, between October 22 and 26, Etsy banned recipes written by AI and published a contract that lets it use sellers' photos, and for sellers, they sound like a contradiction.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Some departing sellers are testing smaller marketplaces built explicitly around human-made work. Alternative anti-AI marketplaces like Marmalade Handmade exist, but they remain small compared to Etsy. Others are leaning on direct sales through their own sites and social channels instead of hunting for a single replacement platform.

Whether the goodwill gesture holds sellers in place is an open question. It remains unclear whether Ossman's clarification will bring sellers back. Etsy has roughly three weeks before the December 16 deadline to turn a promised revision into contract language sellers can actually trust. For a marketplace built on the idea of buying from a real person, that trust is the whole business model.

Check topics and authors from this story to see more stories like this in your personalized feed and receive updates when new work is published.

Advertisement

Advertisement

More

Let's find more interesting stories in AI like this

See all

Advertisement

PakistaniArt uses cookies to remember your preferences, keep the site running smoothly, and understand which stories our readers care about most. We never sell your data. See our Cookie Policy for exactly what we collect and why.